30 July 2015 1421 Views

TRUE DETECTIVE HOME TRUTHS

by James Murphy

TRUE DETECTIVE TRUE BRILLIANCE

 TRUE DETECTVE 3

You might have seen HBO’s TRUE DETECTIVE, series 2. You might not have quite caught up with it yet. So, we’ll avoid spoilers or even a ‘review’ in the strictest sense. Instead, we would like to offer some consideration to the reception the programme has received. We are also giving you some frankly AMAZING artwork inspired by the show. THANK YOU, FRANK MENGARELLI!

In a nutshell: it’s all about EXPECTATION. TRUE DETECTIVE, series one was like catching cinematic lightening in a televisual bottle. We had two great actors: WOODY HARRELSON and MATTHEW MCCONAUGHEY. Imagine pairing those two consummate actors on the big screen. It’d be a hit, right? Of course! So, placing them on television, (albeit high end, pay per view channel, corporate branded stuff) was amazing. It was a real coup, especially given Matthew’s Oscar buzz at the time. But it was the surprise factor of that casting, rather than simply the idea of casting high calibre talent in itself, that arguably fuelled the first series’ success.

TRUE DETECTIVE 1

 

Therefore, ANY actors following those leads had an impossibly tough act to follow. The makers went with similarly high calibre names. We now have COLIN FARRELL and VINCE VAUGHAN. These are ‘name’ actors, once again. They can open movies, albeit with sporadic success rates. Sure, they’ve had a few flops but then so does EVERY major actor / movie star. It’s allowed. These are two men about mid-way through already distinguished yet still promising careers. There are even those who suspect Mr. Farrell will be handed the keys to Tony Stark’s mansion in the event that ROBERT DOWNEY JUNIOR stands down from the IRON MAN franchise. And Vaughan IS funny though can also be dark and deep.

So Farrell/Vaughan SHOULD constitute a MORE than a fitting follow-up to Harrelson /McConaughey. And of course, it is! Except the key words there are ‘follow-up’. They are doomed before they begin, by virtue of being defined AS the ‘B’ team; the second choice; the alternative etc. That inevitably creates a meta-textual barrier to truly embracing the fictional world the characters inhabit. You are dragged AWAY from the material because some part of you simply SENSES that this whole product is manufactured whereas the first series was simply an organic accident of genuine creativity and timing.

TRUE DETECTIVE 4

Rather than expecting the second series to be great, you almost KNOW it cannot be anything like as inspired as its predecessor. That feeling in turn informs the general climate of reviews and a self-fulfilling prophecy takes hold of all; propelled by our era of blogging our views in the viral media.

‘TRUE DETECTIVE series 2 CANNOT POSSIBLY be as good as the first’ we tell ourselves and we find ourselves agreeing with that statement both as we watch and agree in unison with various reviews, as though programmed like Pavlov’s Dog!

TRUE DETECTIVE series 2 IS flawed, yes. Plots appear rather convoluted. Character arcs are neither one thing nor the other: ARE these simply generic pulp beats, spliced together in a shameless pastiche? OR: TRULY something deeper, darker, better?

There are moments whereby the tone and verisimilitude are compromised, because the ambitions, intentions and general brief / ethos of the series remain as murkily unclear as the criminal underworlds their characters inhabit. But once again, that’s a rather meta-textual comment on the show as product than it is a defeat of the material in itself.

The programme has some genuine talent and hard work up on screen. So why not give it a go and judge objectively for yourself, rather than letting it become a victim of the brand’s own success and the legacy of the first series? You MIGHT even LIKE it!

WITH SPECIAL THANKS TO FRANK MENGARELLI!

http://podcastingthemsoftly.com/

 



New

Road to the Oscars: MOONLIGHT
12 February 2017
Road to the Oscars: MOONLIGHT
MOONLIGHT is a prime example of the power of cinema.  The film follows a...

May interest You

No! Shit Sherlock? Or Mr Holmes and the Case of the Television Show that Mysteriously lost its Charm
16 January 2017
No! Shit Sherlock? Or Mr Holmes and the Case of the Television Show that Mysteriously lost its Charm
Get out your Pipes and Magnifying Glasses..and let’s examine a televisual, meta-textual crime scene.....
SPIDER MAN GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY BAYWATCH ASSASSINS CREED APES AT WAR TRANSFORMERS FIFTY SHADES AND VIN DIESEL A PRE CHRISTMAS TRAILER BONANZA!
12 December 2016
SPIDER MAN GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY BAYWATCH ASSASSINS CREED APES AT WAR TRANSFORMERS FIFTY SHADES AND VIN DIESEL A PRE CHRISTMAS TRAILER BONANZA!
The Big Guns are Here. In Every Sense..     It’s beginning to look...
Harry Potter The Good The Bad The Meh The Inspired Genius The Legacy The Future of the Franchise and the Cars
28 November 2016
Harry Potter The Good The Bad The Meh The Inspired Genius The Legacy The Future of the Franchise and the Cars
Whatever you think of the brand, Harry Potter and the associated universe is here...

Popular

The Joys of Meeting John Barrowman and Watching a Great British Pantomime
29 January 2017
The Joys of Meeting John Barrowman and Watching a Great British Pantomime
John Barrowman gives a lesson in what makes a star: professionalism, talent and old...
KAREN BENARDELLO GOES THE ROUNDS ON THE RED CARPET WITH MILES TELLER AND BLEED FOR THIS
20 December 2016
KAREN BENARDELLO GOES THE ROUNDS ON THE RED CARPET WITH MILES TELLER AND BLEED FOR THIS
Karen Benardello gives a Red Carpet insight to Bleed for This: one of 2016’s...

Tags